As the U.S. economy shows sudden weakness, American consumers understandably express increasing anxiety…
CFIF on Twitter CFIF on YouTube
Elizabeth Warren Prepares to Punish the U.S. Economy and Investors with Her Misnamed "Stop Wall Street Looting Act"

As the U.S. economy shows sudden weakness, American consumers understandably express increasing anxiety.  A troubling new Gallup survey reports that economic confidence has now declined to lows unsurpassed since the early days of the Covid pandemic in 2020.

Undeterred by that accumulating weakness and alarm, however, Senator Elizabeth Warren (D - Massachusetts) appears restless to strike yet another dangerous hammer blow by re-introducing her misnamed "Stop Wall Street Looting Act."

She may think that title can conceal the bill's danger, but Americans and elected officials mustn't be fooled or invite the potentially catastrophic economic peril.

Senator Warren’s bill includes significant tax increases, as well as new legal liabilities and bureaucratic regulations on U.S. investment…[more]

October 18, 2021 • 01:48 PM

Liberty Update

CFIFs latest news, commentary and alerts delivered to your inbox.
“Net Neutrality”: Pandemic Vindicates FCC Chairman Ajit Pai Print
By Timothy H. Lee
Thursday, April 23 2020
A greater emphasis on free-market policies and a light-touch regulatory approach brought immediate and measurable improvements to U.S. internet service after a brief scare under the Obama Administration’s European-style 'Net Neutrality' deviation.

Among its other byproducts, the coronavirus pandemic has exposed the asininity of casting every item in leftists’ exhaustive policy wishlist in life-or-death rhetorical terms. 

After all, there’s nothing like an actual existential threat to re-contextualize cheap partisan overuse of the term “existential threat,” from climate change to so-called “Net Neutrality.” 

In 2017, new Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Chairman Ajit Pai moved to repeal a 2015 Obama Administration effort to regulate internet service as a public utility under laws written in the 1930s for copper-wire telephone service. 

The term “Net Neutrality” itself was risible, because there’s nothing “neutral” about the federal government imposing a one-size-fits-all business model upon the internet marketplace, thereby picking winners and losers.  The internet had flourished from 1996 through 2015 under a light-touch regulatory approach, so the Obama Administration’s “Net Neutrality” regulation was the deviation from the two-decade norm. 

Moreover, the negative consequences of the Obama Administration’s “Net Neutrality” effort were immediate and negative.  For the first time outside of an economic recession, the amount of private investment in internet infrastructure actually declined.  In just the first year of the Obama “Net Neutrality” rule, investment fell by a depressing $5.6 billion. 

Accordingly, Chairman Pai led the FCC effort to repeal the destructive Obama Administration rule, and return federal internet service regulation to the light-touch regulatory environment that prevailed from 1996 to 2015, under both Democratic and Republican administrations. 

Leftist response was swift, crude and prototypically dishonest.  Late-night comedians solemnly warned impressionable viewers that the Trump Administration and Chairman Pai would destroy the internet.  Protestors gathered outside Pai’s home, even menacing him and his family.  Writing in Medium in December 2017, Benjamin Sledge openly labeled it a matter of “life and death”: 

Let’s say you need to chat with the Suicide Prevention Lifeline, but can’t afford the supercharged internet package, so you’re stuck with lagging service.  As stated, every second counts when you’re contemplating suicide…  The ramifications are further reaching than just having to deal with buffering on Hulu.  The very fight for the heart of mental health could land squarely on our ability to access the resources we need to grow stronger and healthier.  With every shooting that happens, celebrity suicide, or high school kid who goes home and drowns the world out with headphones to numb his depression and dark thoughts, we know mental health is a massive issue.  The question is now whether we care enough to protect the fight for mental health. 

Unsurprisingly, histrionic predictions of that sort proved empty. 

Instead of “killing the internet,” Chairman Pai’s effort bore immediate fruit.  In the first year alone, U.S. internet speeds increased by 40%, and private infrastructure investment reversed its decline and swung upward in 2018. 

And now, amid the coronavirus pandemic, Chairman Pai’s return to the 1996-2015 light-touch regulatory model has achieved further vindication. 

In Europe, which more broadly follows the Obama Administration’s preferred model of heavier internet regulation, networks have strained under sharply increased bandwidth demand as pandemic quarantines have increased home use for both work and leisure.  American internet service, in contrast, has navigated the new bandwidth demands with less difficulty. 

As The Wall Street Journal editorial board noted, that’s the direct result of policy choices made by the FCC under Chairman Pai: 

Americans perhaps take for granted that their internet hasn’t slowed during the coronavirus pandemic, unlike in Europe where speeds and streaming quality have been reduced so networks don’t collapse.  Credit America’s larger private business investment and lighter regulation.  Europe regulates broadband providers like public utilities similar to the Obama-era net neutrality rule that Mr. Pai rescinded.  Americans working at home would be in a much worse position in this pandemic if the Obama rules were still in place. 

Whereas ten years ago the average American household consumed approximately 44% more data than the average European household, today we consume over three times as much data.  That reflects the fact that in America, private internet providers have invested almost 2.5 times as much money per household than European providers over the past decade. 

The takeaway is obvious. 

A greater emphasis on free-market policies and a light-touch regulatory approach brought immediate and measurable improvements to U.S. internet service after a brief scare under the Obama Administration’s European-style “Net Neutrality” deviation. 

As experience amid the coronavirus pandemic has already established, Americans should be grateful for the FCC’s prescient wisdom under the leadership of Chairman Pai. 

Related Articles :
Quiz Question   
In which century were the first mandatory vaccination laws enacted in the United States?
More Questions
Notable Quote   
 
"At the end of last week, there were 584 container ships idling off the world's ports, waiting to be loaded or unloaded. Disruptions in the bulk cargo sector look to be even worse.Experts suggest the problems are temporary. For instance, Bloomberg columnist Brooke Sutherland maintains that three weeks of declines in ocean freight rates tells us 'the worst may be over for the supply-chain snarls that…[more]
 
 
—Gordon G. Chang, Author of "The Coming Collapse of China"
— Gordon G. Chang, Author of "The Coming Collapse of China"
 
Liberty Poll   

Which is the current greatest day-to-day concern to your family?