In our recent Liberty Update, CFIF sounded the alarm on Gigi Sohn, Joe Biden's dangerously extremist…
CFIF on Twitter CFIF on YouTube
Former U.S. Attorney General Agrees: "Hyperpartisan Gigi Sohn Doesn't Belong at the FCC"

In our recent Liberty Update, CFIF sounded the alarm on Gigi Sohn, Joe Biden's dangerously extremist nominee to the Federal Commission (FCC), noting that, "Ms. Sohn is simply too radical to be confirmed to the FCC at a time when Americans rely more than ever on a thriving internet service sector, and the Biden Administration has only itself to blame for its delay in nominating her."

In today's Wall Street Journal, former acting U.S. Attorney General Matthew Whitaker brilliantly echoes the growing consensus that Ms. Sohn is simply too radical in a commentary entitled "Hyperpartisan Gigi Sohn Doesn't Belong on the FCC":

In addition to her hyperpartisan social-media presence, Ms. Sohn has dubbed Fox News 'state-sponsored propaganda' and has urged the FCC to look into whether Sinclair…[more]

December 01, 2021 • 11:55 AM

Liberty Update

CFIFs latest news, commentary and alerts delivered to your inbox.
Detroit vs. Houston: Laboratories for Liberalism, Conservatism Print
By Timothy H. Lee
Thursday, July 25 2013
[T]he bankrupt city of Detroit provides the latest real-world laboratory application of liberals' agenda.

Liberals incessantly claim fealty to “science,” while falsely caricaturing libertarians and conservatives as the ones stubbornly ideological and averse to real-world facts. 

Scientific method, however, involves objective observation and testing beliefs against results.  In that vein, it is liberals who prove habitually impervious to facts and the disastrous real-world results of their philosophies.   

Take gun control as one recurring example.  Liberals persist in their anti-Second Amendment crusade despite irrefutable data that America’s murder rate has been cut in half over the past three decades even while gun possession has reached record highs and firearms restrictions have drastically receded across America.  Data proves that jurisdictions that relax gun restrictions become safer, whereas jurisdictions that tighten gun restrictions become more dangerous.  According to Dr. John Lott, Jr., he has not encountered a single example either in the United States or abroad that contradicts that causal relationship.  Not one. 

As another example, liberals cling to anthropomorphic global warming hyperbole, even as worldwide temperatures have plateaued over the past two decades.  According to their hypothesis, enormous increases in carbon output should have proportionately increased temperatures over that two-decade period. 

And now, the bankrupt city of Detroit provides the latest real-world laboratory application of liberals’ agenda. 

After all, if tasked with drawing up a policy wish list, liberals would include almost all of the practices that were implemented by Detroit over the past 50 years. 

During that span, the city has exclusively elected Democrats as mayors, including the extremist and racially divisive Coleman Young for 20 years.  It maintained the third-highest income tax in the nation, and just last year doubled its business tax.  Liberals assert that labor unions boost prosperity and benefit workers, and Detroit has remained as hospitable to unions as any city in America.  Its municipal employee force was approximately twice as large per capita as other large cities, and its leaders repeatedly agreed to lavish public employee retirement commitments. 

According to liberals, those are precisely the things that should bring prosperity. 

Instead of prosperity, however, those policies have pulverized Detroit into what we see today.  Since 1950, when it was America’s manufacturing powerhouse after producing a huge portion of the arms that won World War II, its population has plummeted from 1.8 million to 700,000.  Four out of every ten streetlights don’t even function, and in the past five years alone 70% of its parks have closed.  Its crime rate is five times the national average, and its police force has been slashed by 40% in just the past ten years. 

In comparison, the thriving city of Houston provides a real-world laboratory for conservative principles.  It maintains a regulatory light touch and low taxes, refusing to raise tax rates during the post-recession budget shortfall.  “I’d argue we may be the most libertarian city in America,” says Houston Strategies blogger Tory Gattis.  “Live and let live, strong property rights, not much corruption, small-business culture.” 

Unsurprisingly, Houston has prospered.  As summarized by The Wall Street Journal in its interview of Mayor Annise Parker: 

“For the calendar year ending in February, it saw the fastest pace of job growth (4.5%) among the country’s 20 largest metropolitan areas.  (With a population of 2.1 million, it’s the fourth-largest U.S. city.)  In 2011, the last year such data are available, Houston had the fastest-growing large metropolitan economy, at 3.7%.  Add to that a cost of living that is 7.8% below the U.S. average – New York is 53.4% above the average – and you can see the attraction for waves of new arrivals.  Houston costs run a third less than the average in the 29 largest metro areas.  Adjusting for lower costs, Houston has the highest per-capita income of any city in the nation.” 

Confronted with these facts, liberals might scapegoat the domestic auto industry’s decline for Detroit’s ills and attribute Houston’s prosperity to the oil industry.  But that doesn’t withstand scrutiny.  Pittsburgh witnessed a similar decline in the steel industry, yet it and other Midwestern cities prosper relative to Detroit.  Moreover, auto manufacturing itself thrives in more business-friendly Sun Belt states.  Note also that Ford Motor Company refused the big-government federal bailout and as a result is today more valuable than General Motors and Chrysler combined in terms of market and estimated values.  As for Houston, the energy sector has actually decreased from 90% of its economy just 20 years ago to half today.  So that doesn’t explain its prosperity. 

If liberalism worked, then Detroit and Houston would be reversed.  Instead, Detroit has unraveled over the past 50 years into a morass of dysfunction, crime, blight and bankruptcy while Houston has prospered. 

The two cities serve as laboratories of policy, and the results should be clear to liberals as well as conservatives.  Finally accepting that reality can mean fewer future Detroits, and more Houstons. 

Quiz Question   
How many gun purchase background checks were processed by the FBI during Thanksgiving Week 2021?
More Questions
Notable Quote   
 
"If you're still wondering why raising the cap on the State and Local Tax (SALT) deduction was important enough to Democrats to sacrifice their stated principles and resort to brazen gimmicks in order to fit it into the reconciliation bill, look no further than the latest release of the IRS's tax migration data, covering tax years 2018-2019.The data shows that certain states continue to alienate their…[more]
 
 
—Andrew Wilford, Policy Analyst at National Taxpayers Union Foundation
— Andrew Wilford, Policy Analyst at National Taxpayers Union Foundation
 
Liberty Poll   

In your Christmas shopping thus far, how are you faring?