So federal bureaucrats at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), those known master micromanagers of the American economy, concluded in their wisdom to oppose the proposed merger between AT&T and T-Mobile, two independent, free, private parties. Along the way, the FCC went to the improper and unprecedented extreme of releasing a staff report gratuitously and inaccurately critiquing the justifications offered for the merger. Again, we’re talking about a merger between two consenting, informed parties. We’re also talking about a merger application that was voluntarily withdrawn by the parties. Yet the FCC, for reasons still unexplained, broke with decades of administrative protocol and published the staff report.
Remember, this is the same supposedly omnipotent federal government that managed the housing market so well in recent decades through Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, not to mention the splendid business acumen it displayed in the energy sector with such examples as Solyndra. And it’s the same FCC that incompetently attempted to commandeer Internet service through so-called “Net Neutrality,” which earned it a unanimous rebuke from the D.C. Court of Appeals and Congress.
Turning its eye toward the telecommunications industry, the FCC decided in its considered expertise that the AT&T/T-Mobile merger was not in the best interests of the American people. As one particularly curious example, the FCC staff report claims that the proposed merger would cause job losses. One would think that federal regulators would be more circumspect in asserting job projections in light of the slow-motion “stimulus” disaster that was supposed to cap unemployment at 8% in October 2009. Instead, unemployment stands at 9% and has exceeded 8% for a record number of months. Moreover, if the merger was a likely job-killer, why would even the Communication Workers of America (CWA) labor union support it? The FCC asks us to believe that the labor union most impacted by the proposed merger would somehow seek fewer dues-paying members?
Moreover, the FCC itself within the past month claimed that its own $4.5 billion fund to deploy wireline broadband to just 7 million Americans would create “500,000 jobs and $50 billion in economic growth.” Yet it now contradicts itself by claiming the proposed AT&T/T-Mobile merger, which would deploy broadband service to the far greater number of 55 million Americans, would somehow destroy jobs? In other words, the FCC seems to think that smaller amounts of government spending to bring broadband to a smaller number of people will create jobs, but much larger amounts of private investment to bring broadband to a much greater number of people will not.
Federal bureaucrats are unequipped to micromanage the telecom industry, just as they’re incompetent to tell Boeing (America’s top exporter) where it can and cannot operate manufacturing plants. It’s yet another example that the FCC is out of control, and threatening American jobs by its malfeasance.
CFIF on Twitter
CFIF on YouTube