Freedom Line Blog

CFIF recently marked the ignominious one-year anniversary of the Biden Administration’s misnamed “Inflation Reduction Act” (IRA), whose title even Biden himself admitted was mistaken.

We noted how, as a result of the IRA, drug shortages have already reached record highs, increasing by 30% between 2021 and 2022 alone, according to a report in March from the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs.  Another report from the American Cancer Society also sounded the alarm on emerging drug shortages, caused in part by drug price control policies.  Thus, just one year in, drug shortages have reached record levels under the looming threat of drug price controls, weaker intellectual property protections and regulatory browbeating.

This week, as reported by Politico, the same Biden Administration that called inflation “transitory” and insists in the face of public blowback that “Bidenomics” is somehow succeeding announced that it will soon release the first ten prescription drugs selected for its destructive price control scheme:

President Joe Biden has sought to sell health policies like the new Medicare negotiation program as part of a broader ‘Bidenomics’ agenda set to underpin his reelection campaign.  The drug pricing push, he has argued, will help counter inflation and boost the economy by slashing the amount Americans have to shell out each year for critical medicines, although prices negotiated on the first set of drugs won’t take effect until 2026.”

Given Biden’s shoddy record for accuracy and competence so far, Americans will be forgiven for their skepticism.  As we noted, the consequence of price controls will be shortages and less innovation, which we’re already witnessing.  Americans aren’t buying this “Bidenomics” pitch, and will pay a heavy price unless and until these dangerous drug price controls are reversed.

“The record of price controls goes as far back as human history.  They were imposed by the Pharaohs of ancient Egypt.  They were decreed by Hammurabi, king of Babylon, in the eighteenth century B.C.  They were tried in ancient Athens.” -Henry Hazlitt

Today marks the one-year anniversary of Joe Biden’s misnamed “Inflation Reduction Act” (IRA), which even he now admits shouldn’t have carried that title.

Beyond Biden’s own regrets, however, Americans deserve to understand its destructive impact on our healthcare system and world-leading pharmaceutical innovation sector.

Namely, our traditional market-based approach has resulted in an unrivaled legacy of pharmaceutical innovation and abundance relative to the rest of the industrialized world.

For example, the United States accounts for approximately two of every three new lifesaving drugs introduced worldwide, meaning that we alone create twice as many new drugs as the entire world combined.  As another illustration, American consumers enjoy a substantially higher availability of critical drugs compared to people in other advanced economies.  Of 270 new medicines introduced domestically since 2011, only 52% of them were available to our neighbors just across our northern border in Canada, 41% in Australia, 48 % in Japan, 53% in France, 64% in Britain and 67% in Germany.

Destructive drug price controls, however, maintained an illogical appeal for the Biden Administration and the political left.

They can’t say that they couldn’t have foreseen the downsides of the IRA.  Amid debate over broad drug price controls back in 2021, a University of Chicago study warned of their potential negative impact on future drug innovation and availability:

The United States has far fewer restrictions on price than other countries, but the Biden Administration has announced their goal to lower drug prices through greater price regulation. …  [N]ew drug approvals will fall by 32 to 65 approvals from 2021 to 2029 and 135 to 277 approvals from 2030 to 2039.  These significant drops in new drug approvals will lead to delays in needed drug therapies, resulting in worse health outcomes for patients.  

Several years earlier, even the United Nations World Health Organization (WHO) similarly warned about the consequences of government price controls and intellectual property violations:

[P]rice controls, combined with the threat of market lockout or intellectual property infringement, prevent drug companies from charging market rates for their products, while delaying the availability of new cures to patients living in countries implementing those policies.  

Disregarding those warnings and textbook economic logic, the Biden Administration and Pelosi-Schumer Congress plowed ahead with the IRA, whose drug price control provisions President Biden bizarrely trumpets as a 2024 reelection theme.  From branded drugs to off-patent older generics, the Biden Administration accelerated government efforts to artificially target drug prices, oblivious to the foreseeable consequences.

We’re now suffering the consequences of that agenda.

Drug shortages have already reached record highs, increasing by 30% between 2021 and 2022 alone, according to a report earlier this summer from the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs:

Shortages of critical medications continue to rise – including drugs used in hospital emergency rooms and to treat cancer, prescription medications, and even common over-the-counter treatments like children’s cold and flu medicine.  The number of active drug shortages in the U.S. reached a peak of 295 at the end of 2022. …  Between 2021 and 2022, new drug shortages increased by nearly 30 percent.  At the end of 2022, drug shortages experienced a record five-year high of 295 active drug shortages.  

Separately, a new report from the American Cancer Society warns of emerging drug shortages, caused in part by drug pricing policies:

Chemotherapy drugs used to treat cancer are increasingly in short supply and have returned to the list of top-five drug classes affected by shortage.  Expanded demand, supply shortages, limited manufacturing capacity, and low profit margins for generic therapies are among the factors resulting in the current nationwide shortage.  …  A number of the drugs included in the shortage don’t have an effective alternative.  As first-time treatments for a number of cancers, including triple-negative breast cancer, ovarian cancer and leukemia often experienced by pediatric cancer patients, the shortage could lead to delays in treatment that could result in worse outcomes.  

Accordingly, drug shortages have reached record levels under the looming threat of drug price controls, weaker intellectual property protections and regulatory browbeating.

Instead of perpetuating the IRA’s spiral of price control insanity, elected leaders should return to the more market-oriented approach that brought unrivaled innovation before more Americans pay the needless cost.